The financial strength of German life insurers is mainly determined by their returns achieved on the capital markets as well as their profit margin of their insurance business. Customers are looking for financially strong ensurers providing them with a high level of profit participation – in addition to covering the guaranteed interest rated and the sums insured. Given that consumers invest an important portion of their income in life insurance, they are looking for a long-term relationship with insurance partners having good financial health. Insurance brokers, advising their customers on the choice of the life insurer are required to compare life insurers before giving advice. Our ranking provides such an independent benchmark analysis.

Measuring Financial Health.

To quantify a life insurer’s financial health we use the Economic Capital Ratio. It is simply the company’s available capital divided by its assets. This ratio enables us to rank and compare insurers of different size. Indeed, it is not the size that matters, but whether the insurer has the financial means to be resilient in adverse situations. Computing the economic capital of a life insurer is the core of RealRate’s computational model. Picking the most important information from the annual business reports, we transform those accounting values to economic market values. This approach is especially important for German life insurers since their statutory accounting relies on book values often being quite different from fair market values. In addition, their business model and corresponding accounting is difficult and deviates from other industries. The Economic Capital Ratio is a forward-looking key ratio capturing financial health in just one figure.

The first RealRate ranking of German life insurers is now available. The ranking is based on the annual reports for the 2014 financial year and the economic equity ratio. This measures the financial strength that results when the published commercial balance sheet is revalued at fair market values.

The winner is Neue Bayerische Beamten Lebensversicherung, a very young insurance company founded in 1987 and part of the Die Bayerische insurance group. The company thus benefits from low guaranteed interest rates and is not burdened by high guaranteed interest rates of the past. In addition, it has an exceptionally good equity base. ALTE LEIPZIGER Lebensversicherung and HUK-COBURG Lebensversicherung follow in second and third place.

4. Debeka Leben
6.40%

10. LVM Leben
6.03%

12. Swiss Life
5.94%

15. INTER Leben
5.63%

17. uniVersa Leben
5.62%

21. Barmenia Leben
5.32%

22. TARGO Leben
5.15%

24. PB Leben
5.04%

25. AXA Leben
4.90%

26. Allianz Leben
4.76%

29. R + V Leben AG
4.55%

33. SAARLAND Leben
4.23%

35. HELVETIA Leben
4.11%

36. IDUNA Leben
4.07%

37. HDI Leben
4.00%

38. Ideal Leben
3.98%

42. Condor Leben
3.78%

43. RheinLand Leben
3.75%

46. Gothaer Leben
3.51%

48. ERGO Leben
3.38%

49. Generali Leben
3.35%

52. DEVK Leben
3.16%

53. neue leben
2.97%

55. VPV Leben AG
2.55%

56. Basler Leben
2.13%

57. WWK Leben
1.88%

back to Ranking Area